“A person can do what they will, but they cannot will what they will.”
Arthur Schopenhauer · Philosophical pessimism
Philosopher
Last reviewed:
1788–1860 · Philosophical pessimism · Modern
Arthur Schopenhauer argued that the world as we know it is representation, and that the inner nature of that world is will, a blind striving with no final goal. The World as Will and Representation begins from a Kantian claim about appearance and then leaves Kant behind. Aesthetic contemplation, for him, is one of the few pauses in the striving.
Compassion is the basis of morality, because it is the crack in the usual wall between self and other. He is darker than the Stoics and more systematic than a book of aphorisms, and he is ruder about Hegel than a fair history would be. The prize essays on freedom and on morality are the short way into the ethics.
The big book is the way into the metaphysics. English readers should name a translation, E. F. J. Payne's for the major work, because 'idea' in older versions makes Vorstellung sound like a thought you could correct. He influenced Nietzsche and, less officially, a strain in Wittgenstein. He is not a self-help pessimist. The pessimism is a conclusion he thinks the metaphysics forces.
Two essays and the book's first sentence are secured. A fourth motto was not added. The system does not naturally shed one-line quotations that stay accurate.
The opening section of The World as Will and Representation in Payne, then the 1840 essay on morality.
The first sentence is famous and incomplete. The morality essay is where the system becomes an ethics you can accept or refuse without swallowing every page of the will.
“A person can do what they will, but they cannot will what they will.”
Arthur Schopenhauer · Philosophical pessimism
“Compassion is the basis of morality.”
Arthur Schopenhauer · Philosophical pessimism
“The world is my representation.”
Arthur Schopenhauer · Philosophical pessimism
Representation
The world as object is always the world for a subject. That is the opening, not yet the gloom.
Will
Striving, not a rational plan, is what he thinks representation is a veil for.
Compassion
The only genuine moral incentive, against Kant's empty form of duty.
Denial
Aesthetic quiet and ascetic denial are the exits he offers from the will. They are rare.
The World as Will and Representation (1818)
Volume 1 states the system. Volume 2 expands it.
On the Freedom of the Will (1839)
You can do what you will, but you cannot will what you will.
On the Basis of Morality (1840)
The prize essay against Kant, with compassion as the moral incentive.
None of the lines this library files for Arthur Schopenhauer is marked Questionable or Misattributed. That is only a fact about these cards. It is not a certificate that every popular sentence is theirs.
The opening section of The World as Will and Representation in Payne, then the 1840 essay on morality. The first sentence is famous and incomplete. The morality essay is where the system becomes an ethics you can accept or refuse without swallowing every page of the will.
This library does not measure fame, and it does not rank lines by how often they are shared. The first line it files for Arthur Schopenhauer that is not marked Questionable or Misattributed is “A person can do what they will, but they cannot will what they will.” (On the Freedom of the Will (1839), a standard English of his formulation, Paraphrase or translation).
None of the lines this library files for Arthur Schopenhauer is marked Misattributed or Questionable. That is a fact about these cards, not a certificate that every popular sentence is theirs.
Representation: The world as object is always the world for a subject. That is the opening, not yet the gloom.